Existential experience vs. mystical experience: Leontiev and Dostoyevsky
Publication Title:
Existential experience vs. mystical experience: Leontiev and Dostoyevsky
Abstract:
On the basis of the comparative method the differences in the religious experiences of F.M. Dostoevsky and K.N. Leontiev are explored. The author defends the thesis that it was this difference that first of all caused ideological contradictions between these thinkers, in particular, a sharp disagreement on the problem of the attainability of “universal harmony” in the world. It is shown that the basis of Dostoevsky's religious faith was a kind of mystical experience – the experience of self-transcendence and unity with the eternal sources of being, with Christ and with mankind. The author maintains that the peculiarity of Dostoevsky's mystical experience lies in the fact that it is based mainly on moral intuitions – the intuition of respect for every human person and the intuition of love for Christ – which, due to their extreme intensity, acquire the character of a religious revelation. It is proved that Dostoevsky's most important ideas, such as the possibility of universal harmony, the necessity to transform the human heart by means of sacrificial love and compassion, every man’s responsibility for all humanity, have mystical origins. The author shows that, on the contrary, Leontiev's religious worldview, which the philosopher himself called “mysticism”, was based not on mystic, but on existential experience. The author comes to the conclusion that existential philosophizing, based on the experience of boundary situations of dread and despair, was for Leontiev a way of obtaining the peace in faith and of developing his Christian worldview.
References:
(Sources)
1. Ruysbroeck the Admirable. Odeyanie dukhovnogo braka [The Spiritual Espousals]. Moscow, 1910. 272 p.
Collected Works
2. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Prestuplenie i nakazanie [Crime and Punishment], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 6 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 6]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1973. 424 p.
3. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Idiot [The Idiot], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 8 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 8]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1973. 512 p.
4. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Idiot: Podgotovitel'nye materialy [The Idiot: preparatory materials], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 9 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 9]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1973, pp. 140–288.
5. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Besy [The Possessed], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 10 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 10]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1974. 519 p.
6. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Brat'ya Karamazovy. Kn. I–X [The Brothers Karamazov. Books I–X], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 14 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 14]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1976. 511 p.
7. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Zapisnaya knizhka 1863–1864 gg. [The notebook of 1863–1864], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t. T. 20. Stat'i i zametki 1862–1865 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 20. Articles and notes 1862–1865]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1980, pp. 170–179.
8. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Dnevnik pisatelya za 1876 god. May–oktyabr' [A Writer's Diary. 1876, May–October], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 23 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 23]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1981. 423 p.
9. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Zapisnaya tetrad' 1876–1877 gg. [The notebook of 1876–1877], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 24. Dnevnik pisatelya za 1876 god. Noyabr' – dekabr' [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 24. A Writer's Diary. 1876, November–December]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1982, pp. 187–314.
10. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Son smeshnogo cheloveka. Fantasticheskiy rasskaz [The Dream of a Ridiculous Man: a fantastical tale], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 25. Dnevnik pisatelja za 1877 god. Janvar'–avgust [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 25. A Writer's Diary. 1877, January–August]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1983, pp. 104–119.
11. Dostoevskiy, F.M. Dnevnik pisatelya. 1881 [A Writer's Diary. 1881], in Dostoevskiy, F.M. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy v 30 t., t. 27 [Complete works in 30 vols., vol. 27]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1984. 460 p.
12. Leont'ev, K.N. Zapiski otshel'nika [Notes of a hermit], in Leont'ev, K.N. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy i pisem v 12 t., t. 8, kn. 1 [Complete works and letters in 12 vols., vol. 8, book 1]. Saint-Petersburg: Vladimir Dal', 2007, pp. 234–496.
13. Leont'ev, K.N. Moe obrashchenie i zhizn' na Sv. Afonskoy gore [My conversion and life on Mount Athos], in Leont'ev, K.N. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy i pisem v 12 t., t. 6, kn. 1 [Complete works and letters in 12 vols., vol. 6, book 1]. Saint-Petersburg: Vladimir Dal', 2003, pp. 782–804.
14. Leont'ev, K.N. Strakh Bozhiy i lyubov' k chelovechestvu. Po povodu rasskaza gr. L.N. Tolstogo «Chem lyudi zhivy?» [Fear of God and love of mankind. Concerning the story gr. L.N. Tolstoy “What do people live by?”], in Leont'ev, K.N. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy i pisem v 12 t., t. 9 [Complete works and letters in 12 vols., vol. 9]. Saint-Petersburg: Vladimir Dal', 2014, pp. 165–186.
15. Leont'ev, K.N. Chetyre pis'ma s Afona [Four letters from Athos], in Leont'ev, K.N. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy i pisem v 12 t., t. 7, kn. 1 [Complete works and letters in 12 vols., vol. 7, book 1]. Saint-Petersburg: Vladimir Dal', 2005, pp. 131–175.
16. Leont'ev, K.N. Pis'ma 1891 goda [Letters of 1891], in Leont'ev, K.N. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy i pisem v 12 t., t. 12, kn. 3 [Complete works and letters in 12 vols., vol. 12, book 3]. Saint-Petersburg: Vladimir Dal', 2021, pp. 7–240.
Individual Works
17. Anderkhill, E. Mistitsizm. Opyt issledovaniya prirody i zakonov razvitiya dukhovnogo soznaniya cheloveka [Mysticism: A Study of the Nature and Development of Man's Spiritual Consciousness]. Kiev: Sofija, 2000. 496 p.
18. Berdyaev, N.A. Filosofiya svobody [The Philosophy of Freedom]. Moscow: OLMA-PRESS, 2000. 351 p.
19. Bol'nov, O.F. Filosofiya ekzistentsializma [The Philosophy of Existentialism]. Saint-Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo «Lan'», 1999. 224 p.
20. Gol'dt, R. Asketizm kak transtsendental'naya forma zaboty o sebe u K.N. Leont'eva [Asceticism as a transcendental form of self-care in K.N. Leontiev's Works], in Sbornik statey «Izobilie i askeza v russkoy literature: stolknoveniya, perekhody, sovpadeniya» [Collection of Articles “Abundance and Asceticism in Russian Literature: Collisions, Transitions, Coincidences”]. Moscow, Redaktsiya zhurnala «Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie», 2020, pp. 72–84.
21. K'erkegor, S. Zaklyuchitel'noe nenauchnoe posleslovie k «Filosofskim krokham» [Concluding Unscientific Postscript to the Philosophical Fragments]. Moscow: Akademicheskiy Proekt, 2012. 608 p.
22. K'erkegor, S. Ili–ili. Fragment iz zhizni: v 2 ch. [Either/Or. A fragment of life: in 2 part]. Saint-Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo RKhGA: Amfora, 2011. 823 p.
23. K'erkegor, S. Ponyatie strakha [The Concept of Anxiety], in K'erkegor, S. Strakh i trepet [Fear and Trembling]. Moscow: Respublika, 1993, pp. 113–248.
24. K'erkegor, S. Strakh i trepet [Fear and Trembling], in K'erkegor, S. Strakh i trepet [Fear and Trembling]. Moscow: Respublika, 1993, pp. 13–112.
25. Yaspers, K. Filosofiya. Kniga 2. Prosvetlenie ekzistentsii [Philosophy. Book 2. Existential elucidation]. Moscow: Kanon+ ROOI « Reabilitatsiya», 2012. 448 p.
26. Yaspers, K. Filosofiya. Kniga 3. Metafizika [Philosophy. Book 3. Metaphysics]. Moscow: Kanon+ ROOI « Reabilitatsiya», 2012. 296 p.
(Articles from Scientific Journals)
27. Kotel'nikov, V.A. Lichnost' K.N. Leont'eva v svete idey personalizma [The personality of K.N. Leontiev in the light of the ideas of personalism], in Russko-vizantiyskiy vestnik, 2022, no. 4(11), pp. 59–69.
28. Kuz'mina, T.A. Ekzistentsial'nyy opyt i filosofiya [Existential experience and philosophy], in Voprosy filosofii, 2007, no. 12, pp. 16–27.
(Monographs)
29. Kasavina, N.A. Ekzistentsial'nyy opyt v filosofii i sotsial'no-gumanitarnykh naukakh [Existential experience in philosophy and social and human sciences]. Moscow: IFRAN, 2015. 189 p.
30. Laut, R. Filosofiya Dostoevskogo v sistematicheskom izlozhenii [Dostoevsky's philosophy in a systematic presentation]. Moscow: Respublika, 1996. 447 p.
31. Malevich, T.V. Teorii misticheskogo opyta: istoriografiya i perspektivy [Theories of Mystical experience: Historiography and perspectives]. Moscow: IFRAN, 2014. 175 p.
32. Volodikhin, D.M. «Vysokomernyy strannik». Filosofiya i zhizn' Konstantina Leont'eva [“The proud pilgrim”. The philosophy and life of Konstantin Leontiev]. Moscow: Manufaktura, 2000. 192 p.
Key words:
Christian mysticism, mystical experience, universal harmony, existential experience, existential dread, existential despair, Christian faith
The DOI index:
10.17588/2076-9210.2025.2.122-138
Publication file:
