“Justification of Good” or “benefit of evil”: V. Solovyov and K. Lorenz about the natural Foundations of Morality
Publication Title:
“Justification of Good” or “benefit of evil”: V. Solovyov and K. Lorenz about the natural Foundations of Morality
Abstract:
Based on the introductory sections of the treatise “The Justification of Goodˮ and some paragraphs of the book “The So-called evil: The Natural History of Aggressionˮ a comparative analysis of V. Solovyov's ethical and philosophical concept of the natural foundations of morality and K. Lorenz's natural scientific hypothesis about the evolutionary benefits of aggression is carried out. It is shown, that despite all the differences in the form and content of the two theories being compared both of them proceed from the principle of interconnectedness of the transition from biological forms of behavior to social relations. For Solovyov the natural roots of the three foundations of morality as such a connecting link. Lorenz has an ambivalence of aggression, which can manifest itself in different ways in intraspecific and group selection. At the same time, the fundamental differences between the theories under consideration in the issues of the origin and essence of the natural foundations of morality are noted. Despite the additional introduction of such a specifically sensual form as conscience, Solovyov's conception of the natural foundations of the non-natural idea of goodness looks like a pantheistic concession to theism. Lorenz having identified the positive role of aggression in intraspecific selection finds the origins of behavior similar to morality in communities of living beings. It is precisely such proto-moral behaviors that do not completely eliminate, but weaken and inhibit innate aggression. The general conclusions of the article note Vladimir Solovyov's contribution to the formation of the modern picture of the world, and also state the different understanding of the dual nature of man by the Russian philosopher and the Austrian scientist with the general similarity of the thesis of his creation and progressive incompleteness.
References:
(Sources)
Collected Works
1. Solov'ev, V.S. Opravdanie dobra. Nravstvennaya filosofiya [Justification of goodness. Moral Philosophy], in Solov'ev V.S. Sochineniya v 2 t., t. 1 [Works in 2 vols., vol. 1]. Moscow: Mysl', 1990, pp. 47‒580.
2. Solov'ev, V.S. Kritika otvlechennykh nachal [Criticism of abstract principles], in Solov'ev V.S. Sochineniya v 2 t., t. 1 [Works in 2 vols., vol. 1]. Moscow: Mysl', 1990, pp. 581‒831.
Individual Works
3. Lorents, K. Tak nazyvaemoe zlo: K estestvennoy teorii agressii [The So-called evil: The Natural History of Aggression], in Lorents, K. Tak nazyvaemoe zlo [The So-called evil]. Moscow: Kul'turnaya revolyutsiya, 2008, pp. 86‒308.
4. Losev, A.F. Strast' k dialektike: Literaturnye razmyshleniya filosofa [Passion for Dialectics: Literary Reflections of a Philosopher]. Moscow: Sovetskiу pisatel', 1990. 320 p.
5. Trubetskoy, E.N. Mirosozertsanie Vl.S. Solov'eva. T. 1 [The worldview of V.S. Solovyov. Vol. 1]. Moscow: Tovarishchestvo tip. A.I. Mamontova, 1913. 652 p.
(Articles from Scientific Journals)
6. Ehlen, P. “Impersonalismus” und die “Werdende Vernunft der Wahrheit” in Solov'evs Spätphilosophie [“Impersonalismˮ and “expectant sense of truthˮ in later philosophy of Solovyov’s], in Studies in East European Thought, Dordrecht, 1999, no. 51(3), pp. 155‒175.
7. Evlampiev, I.I., Matveeva, I.Yu. Religioznye ucheniya L. Tolstogo i Vl. Solov'eva i problema edinstva russkoy filosofii [The religious teachings of L. Tolstoy and V. Solovyov and the problem of the Unity of Russian philosophy], in Istoriko-filosofskiy ezhegodnik, 2019, vol. 34, pp. 222–249.
8. Gaisin, A. Solovyov’s Metaphysics between Gnosis and Theurgy, in Religions, 2018, vol. 9(11), no. 354, pp. 1‒10.
9. Gaydenko, P.P. Iskushenie dialektikoy. Panteisticheskie i gnosticheskie motivy u Gegelya i Vl. Solov'eva [The temptation of dialectics. Pantheistic and Gnostic motifs in Hegel and V. Solovyov], in Voprosy filosofii, 1998, no. 4, pp. 75‒93.
10. Khelleman, V.E. Sofiya V.S. Solov'eva i Beatriche Dante [Sofia V.S. Solovyova and Beatrice Dante], in Solov'evskie issledovaniya, 2023, issue 1(77), pp. 65‒79.
11. Kondrat'eva, N.N. Agressiya: ot kontseptsii K. Lorentsa k sovremennym predstavleniyam [Aggression: from the concept of K. Lorenz to modern concepts], in Priroda, 2008, no. 9, pp. 60‒63.
12. Mezhuev, B.V. Pervoe izdanie «Opravdaniya dobra» (1897 g.): otkliki sovremennikov. Ch. 4 [The First Edition of “The Justification of Good” (1897): Contemporaries’ Response. Part 4], in Solov'evskie issledovaniya, 2023, issue 4(80), pp. 6‒22.
13. Obolevich, T. Motiv evolyutsii v tvorchestve V.S. Solov'eva [The motive of evolution in the work of V.S. Solovyov], in Solov'evskie issledovaniya, 2009, issue 4(24), pp. 112‒122.
14. Volkov, Yu.K. Ideya V.S. Solov'eva ob avtonomnosti nravstvennoy zhizni cheloveka i problema estestvennykh osnovaniy etiki dobra [V.S. Solovyov's idea of the autonomy of the moral life of man and the problem of the natural foundations of the ethics of goodness], in Solov'evskie issledovaniya, 2017, issue 3(55), pp. 6–17.
(Articles from Proceedings and Collections of Research Papers)
15. Bulgakov, S. Priroda v filosofii Vl. Solov'eva [Nature in the philosophy of V. Solovyov], in Sbornik statey o V. Solov'eve [Collection of articles about V. Solovyov]. Brussels: Izdatel'stvo «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1994, pp. 5‒42.
16. Nizhnikov, S.A. Vl. Solov'ev i spor o panteizme v russkoy filosofii [Russian Philosopher Vladimir Solovyov and the dispute about Pantheism in Russian Philosophy], in Materialy mezhdunarodnoi konferentsii «Minuvshee i neprekhodyashchee v zhizni i tvorchestve V.S. Solov'eva», seriya «Symposium», vyp. 32, Sankt-Peterburg, 14–15 fevralya 2003 g. [Proceedings of the international conference “The past and eternal in the life and work of V.S. Solovyov”, series “Symposium”, issue 32, Saint-Petersburg, February 14–15, 2003]. Saint-Petersburg: Sankt-Petersburgskoe filosofskoe obshchestvo, 2003, pp. 305‒307.
(Monographs)
17. Gaydenko, P.P. Vladimir Solov'ev i filosofy Serebryanogo veka [Vladimir Solovyov and the Philosophers of the Silver Age]. Moscow: Progress-Traditsiya, 2001. 472 p.
18. Helleman, W.E. Solovyov's Sophia as a Nineteenth-Century Russian Appropriation of Dante's Beatrice. Lewiston NY: Mellen, 2010. 403 p.
19. Ivanov, A.V., Fotieva, I.V., Shishin, M.Yu. Filosofiya mysli: novye grani metafiziki vseedinstva [Philosophy of Thought: new facets of the Metaphysics of Unity (monograph)]. Barnaul: Novyy format, 2021. 282 p.
20. Kozyrev, A.P. Solov'ev i gnostiki [Solovyov and the Gnostics]. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo «Savin S.A.», 2007. 544 p.
21. Obolevitch, T. Faith and Science in Russian Religious Thought. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019. 220 p.
(Thesis and Thesis Abstracts)
22. Gorokhov, S.A. Filosofskiy analiz etologii Konrada Lorentsa. Avtoref. diss. … kand. filos. nauk [A Philosophical analysis of the ethology of Konrad Lorenz. Abstract of the cand. philos. sci. diss.]. Moscow, 2003. 16 р.
23. Salova, S.E. Evolyutsionnaya epistemologiya Konrada Lorentsa. Avtoref. diss. … kand. filos. nauk [The Evolutionary Epistemology of Konrad Lorenz. Abstract of the cand. philos. sci. diss.] Moscow, 2003. 31 p.
Key words:
morality, aggression, natural foundations of morality, evolution, theism, pantheism, ethology, intraspecific selection, mechanisms of inhibition of aggression
The DOI index:
10.17588/2076-9210.2025.1.018-025
Publication file:
